$ essay

The Great Acid: How IT Eats Middlemen (And Why They Keep Growing Back)

5 min read · one coffee's worth ;) source original

Every middleman in human history has survived by monetizing one of two commodities: ignorance (“I know where the grain is, and you don’t”) or friction (“Moving money, verifying trust, or translating formats is far too complicated for two strangers to handle on their own”). Information Technology is the universal acid for both. Strip away the conference keynotes and venture-capital jargon, and the entire arc of computing—from packet switching and public-key cryptography to local open-weight models and agentic tool protocols—is a relentless engine designed to drive coordination costs toward zero. Whenever coordination costs collapse, entire priesthoods of gatekeepers suddenly find themselves scrambling to explain why society still owes them a 15% vig.


1. Ronald Coase in Reverse

In 1937, the economist Ronald Coase asked a deceptively simple question: If free markets are so efficient, why do giant corporations and sprawling bureaucracies exist at all? His Nobel Prize-winning answer was transaction costs. Discovering suppliers, negotiating contracts, verifying quality, and enforcing payments used to be so expensive in time and trust that it was cheaper to herd thousands of people inside rigid institutional hierarchies.

IT runs Coase’s theorem in reverse. When bits move at the speed of light and cryptographic proofs verify themselves in microseconds, the institutional scaffolding built to manage friction starts dissolving from the inside out. We have watched this acid eat through three distinct layers of the economy:

Wave One: Bits and Gatekeepers

For centuries, broadcast networks, publishing houses, record labels, and credentialed cartels thrived because they owned the physical bottlenecks of printing presses, radio towers, and shelf space. Once copying and routing information became virtually free, information scarcity evaporated—triggering what former CIA analyst Martin Gurri famously called the Revolt of the Public. When anyone can publish, audit primary sources, and route around editorial choke points, legacy gatekeepers lose their monopoly on reality.

Wave Two: Value and Identity

Once bits were free, middlemen retreated to the vaults—claiming their fees were necessary to vouch for who you are and whether your money is good. Traditional correspondent banking, clearinghouses, and centralized single-sign-on brokers built multi-layered toll roads out of institutional trust: “Trust our brand, trust our compliance department, and wait three business days for settlement.” Public-key cryptography, open payment rails, and self-IdeasovereigntyYou, not a landlord, get the last word on your life, your attention, and your machine. It is a practical right, not a costume you put on for the argument. identity architectures replace institutional trust with mathematical verification. You don’t need a hall monitor to vouch for a signature you can verify yourself.

Wave Three: Cognition and the 2026 “SaaSpocalypse”

Right now, IT is doing something even funnier: it is disintermediating earlier generations of IT. For twenty years, horizontal enterprise software companies built fortunes charging $150 per seat per month to sit between human workers and a relational database behind a glossy dashboard. That entire layer of CRUD middleware existed because humans needed visual translation tools to read and write structured records.

As autonomous AI agents connect directly to raw systems of record through open standards like the Model Context Protocol (MCP), those decorative middlemen are being bypassed in real time. When an agent can inspect schemas, authenticate with scoped keys, and orchestrate multi-step workflows across raw TechAPIThe menu of requests one program lets another program make. Whoever writes the menu decides what you are allowed to order. in milliseconds, a bloated per-seat SaaS subscription starts looking like a tollbooth standing in the middle of an empty field.


2. The Two-Step Comedy of Re-Intermediation

If IT is such a potent solvent for middlemen, why does the modern internet still feel like a feudal estate patrolled by digital landlords?

Because every wave of disintermediation creates a temporary power vacuum—and nature abhors an unmonetized bottleneck. Over the past thirty years, Silicon Valley has perfected a two-step bait-and-switch:

  1. Disintermediation as a Battle Cry: A brash newcomer uses software to blow up a sleepy cartel. The open web obliterates travel agents, classified ads, and physical record stores. Everyone celebrates the death of the middleman.
  2. Re-Intermediation as a Business Model: Once the old guard is dead, the newcomer captures the new discovery or identity layer and erects a bigger, sleeker tollbooth. We killed the record label only to get streaming monopolies; we killed the local taxi dispatcher only to get algorithmic surge pricing; we killed the cable bundle only to get 30% app-store taxes and engagement-throttled feeds.

We are watching that exact trap spring shut again in agentic commerce. AI assistants are rapidly disintermediating traditional search engines, affiliate review blogs, and web storefronts. Yet if three frontier AI interfaces become the default shopping concierge for billions of buyers, they simply become the new shelf-placement gatekeepers—deciding which merchant gets recommended and which disappears into the void. Swapping a suit-and-tie broker for an API landlord with a Terms of Service kill switch isn’t liberation. It’s just a dark-mode UI upgrade for the tax collector.


3. How to Make the Acid Stick: Protocols Over Platforms

So when does IT actually liberate the edges instead of merely crowning a new king? When the intelligence, identity, and settlement live in open protocols rather than proprietary platforms.

The distinction is architectural, not moral:

  • Platforms centralize the identity graph, custody the payment rail, and reserve the right to rewrite the rules after you move in. They disintermediate your old landlord only to become your new one.
  • Protocols—like TCP/IP, SMTP, RSS, BitTorrent, MCP, open cryptographic settlement rails, and federated personal data stores—push intelligence and state all the way out to the TechendpointA web address a program sends requests to and gets answers back from. Whoever runs it sees every request that arrives.. When two peers speak an open protocol and hold their own cryptographic keys, there is no center left to capture, no bottleneck to rent-seek on, and no single throat to choke.

Pairing open protocols with local, user-controlled compute—running open-weight models on your own silicon rather than renting every thought from a metered cloud—completes the jailbreak. When your agent runs locally, authenticates with your keys, and transacts over open rails, the middleman has nowhere left to stand.


Let the Solvent Work

Middlemen never go quietly. Five minutes before an Techopen sourceCode anyone may read, run, change, and share. You do not have to trust the builder, because you can check the work yourself. protocol routes around them like network damage, they will inevitably rebrand their tollbooth as “essential consumer protection,” “trusted curation,” or “necessary safety infrastructure.”

Don’t fall for the costume change. Information Technology was never meant to build shinier digital castles for rent-seekers; it was built to let sovereign peers coordinate directly in broad daylight. Keep your keys in your own pocket, build on open protocols, run intelligence at the edge—and let the acid do its job.

Related: The Collapse of the Broadcast Funnel · The Alchemical Matrix of Disintermediation · The Cost of Renting Your Own Tools · Open Weights Are Data · The Proprietary Guild · MapleSpike Costs Nothing to Leave

A Neural Network

Reverb256 Spotify ↗ music